Fanciful (and not so fanciful) scenarios for investors to consid
The yield on the benchmark 10 year Treasury bond hit 3.94% on Friday. Yields
are rising. This is bad for stocks, as equities compete with debt as an
investment, and debt is growing ever more attractive.
The sky isn’t falling yet. We’ve visited these yield levels several times
since the recovery began, once every few months it seems.
The fanciful scenarios of the title are two concerns. What if the bond market
saturates, and there is no more capacity for more debt to be issued? What if
there is a crisis of confidence in US Treasuries?
What evidence do we have for these fanciful scenarios? The recent auctions
have been poorly subscribed. Yields have risen sharply. There is a fear that the
demand/supply relation may not be elastic, and at some point, buyers simply
won’t exist for the debt the government is trying to push, regardless of the
price. A frozen debt market isn’t so unthinkable, as we witnessed it in 2008 and
part of 2009. The market for certain municipal bonds froze, and the market for
corporate debt became severely impaired.
It isn’t hard for me to imagine there being a finite pool of capital
available to buy debt, and for the huge issuances of Treasuries to begin to
“drain the pool”, like an oil well. At some point, the gusher becomes a trickle,
and eventually the oil is all used up.
Another related problem is the possibility of a crisis of confidence in
Treasury bonds. Any sort of irregularity in the Treasury bond market could
trigger, in effect, a run on the bank. Even the rumor of an irregularity. Yields
would shoot up, or the market for Treasuries would freeze, and the government
couldn’t fund its operations.
Some weight must be attached to these fanciful scenarios but how much or
little is the question. It isn’t unthinkable for there to be a run on government
debt. It isn’t unthinkable for the government bond market to reach full
capacity, preventing further sales. I don’t think they’re likely, but unlikelier
things have happened. Until Lehman collapsed and the debt markets seized, no one
thought that was possible or likely either.
The likelier possibility is not the black/white, crisis/no crisis but rather
a shade of grey/partial crisis. A spike in yields is likely as some point,
because yields are likely to go up at some point. What would this mean for
stocks?
A yield spike would not be good for stocks. It essentially puts bonds on
sale, and makes stocks look expensive. A stock market correction, if not a bear
market, is the likely outcome.
What about a minor crisis of confidence in Treasuries? This crisis, as I
imagine it, would raise yields even more, but not freeze the market. The frozen
Treasury market scenario is Armageddon, plain and simple, as 20% of our economy
would stop. A yield spike would hurt equities, by making them look more
expensive, and putting bonds on sale, and hurt businesses that depend on
borrowing. A yield spike in a fragile economy could cause a double-dip
recession, or even a depression, depending how high the rates went. Equities
fall an average of 40% in recessions.
The point of this post is that although the economy is recovering and the
stock market is thriving on improving economic fundamentals, none of it may
matter depending how the interest rate situation plays out in the next few
years. The equity market is the bond market’s b****h. Stocks have been thriving
in a flat interest-rate environment. That environment is about to change;
interest rates have nowhere to go but up. Even long-term rates have remained
relatively constant over the last year. IEF, the 7-10 year Treasury bond ETF,
fell -4.11% in the rolling 1 year period to 4/2/10. What if it falls 30% in the
next year? Will stocks just shrug off that headwind? Do you want to hold stocks
during the rise? Bonds? Gold?
There are some good things about higher interest rates of course. It
encourages savings. However, low interest rates are widely viewed as strong
economic stimulus, which we need to have a healthy post-recession recovery. Home
buyers, businesses looking to expand, and businesses with debts to service all
face higher costs when interest rates are high. Higher costs are inflicted on
consumers, who consume less.
So to wind all this up, we’re likely to see higher interest rates, possibly
under severe duress, or more likely under mild duress, natural market forces, or
Fed decree. This will reduce consumption by placing higher costs on businesses,
which will pass this on to consumers. Consumption is 2/3 of the economy, so the
economy will slow. I just can’t see any way this will be good for stocks. Maybe
necessary medicine to keep the economy strong, but this will catalyze a “real”
10-20% pullback in stocks, at least, at some point this year or next. And I
can’t see it being good for gold or bonds either. The dollar is likely to
continue to strengthen though, making currency perhaps the best investment for a
rising-rates environment. Shorting the Euro, long the dollar, seem like good
bets for the rest of the year. Published By Bloominonion Sunday, April 04, 2010
